[Pkg-utopia-maintainers] Bug#879484: Network-Manager should Default to Non-Random MAC Address on WiFi

Jérôme jerome at jolimont.fr
Mon Nov 20 08:54:45 UTC 2017


I was hit by this too.

This is what I understand:

This setting is enabled by default for privacy/security reasons. It 
makes connection fail with some HW/drivers due to the drivers 
themselves, so the rootcause is not in network-manager itself.

This results in poor user experience for impacted users but the devs may 
not be willing to sacrifice security to workaround an issue in buggy 
drivers.

Is this a setting that could be exposed in a GUI such as 
network-manager-gnome? Could it be an acceptable compromise?

The user with a connection issue would open the connection settings 
dialog et found a checkbox:

   [X] Randomize MAC address during scan

There would be a tooltip explaining that while this might be desirable, 
it is known to cause issues on some HW/drivers. The user would uncheck 
it and try again.

Should we open a bug on network-manager-gnome for this?

-- 
Jérôme



More information about the Pkg-utopia-maintainers mailing list